Originally Posted by
positano
Had our first visit last night, and I may have jinxed myself by setting my expectations way too high. I don't want to hack on the place, but thought this might provided some balance. I would still recommend folks try it.
We had a reservation, and were seated precisely on time. I was afraid it was going to be really noisy, but surprisingly, conversation was really manageable in the booth. Whether by design or not, the booths do a great job of containing the general noise of that big, open room.
Service was excellent. Our server knew the menu well and was very helpful. We struggled to figure out how much to order, and were really pleased she didn't push us to make our entire order at once. We added a few things on as we ate. Her advice on how much to order (group of 4) was spot on.
Raw oyster selection was nice - we went straight to a dozen Kumamotos, a favorite of ours. I don't recall the exact name, but the mignonette with yuzu and jalapeño was the table winner. The Four "H" Hushpuppies were outstanding. Almost a fight over the last one.
Food went a little downhill from there. Roasted carrot salad, sea scallop ceviche, and lobster roll were all fine, but not exciting. We thought the ceviche was certainly fresh, but a bit bland. The meat in the lobster roll was very good, but it seemed like a lot of bread compared to the amount of filling. The seared hiramasa was a nice piece of fish (and a nice size for an entree if dining alone), but I didn't leave craving more. We all shared the paella, which I found under-seasoned as well. I prefer my paella with a pretty strong saffron flavor, and we couldn't really decide what the "forward flavor" was, but was not saffron. There also wasn't much in the way of socarrat, which is our favorite part. I scraped up what I could, but I was hoping for more.
The lemon cloud pie was best in show. Our server said it was her favorite on the menu, and it lived up to her recommendation. A bit like Key Lime Pie, and the graham cracker crust was perfect.
Certainly a nice experience, but I much prefer the other restaurants in the group. In fact, ate lunch at RePublic today, and the tuna tartare was (I thought) a better seafood dish than what I had last night. May be just personal preference, and I really wanted to love this place, but it fell a bit short for me.
Bookmarks