BTW, I have not seen one person "bashing" or "hating" or even suggesting this project isn't awesome for Uptown/23rd and OKC in general.
This site exists to give everyone a voice, and opinions and ideas are generally expressed in a pretty respectful way. Go read the comment section of the Oklahoman if you want to see how badly these things tend to go elsewhere.
We already have the Chamber of Commerce, The Oklahoma and scores of other civic groups that do nothing but cheerlead and provide blind boosterism. So, if that is what you want to read, you have plenty of great sources.
People here should be able to express concerns, disappointment and even criticism without being labeled as some sort of infidel. Otherwise, where is this type of open discussion going to happen?
In fact, it's critical to OKC becoming a better, more engaged community. It's also a crucial part of raising standards, which pretty much everyone agrees are way too low in OKC.
When I was investigating the TEEMCO story (which is on-going, BTW) someone I interviewed said something very astute: "OKC is a great place for a con".
And it's true because of the overwhelming desire of the community -- driven largely by the powers that be -- to suppress conflict and divert attention from bad news.
It's like the parents that never argue. Superficially, that seems to be a good thing when in fact it's completely unhealthy with frequently grave consequences.
I guess the question is whether we want an entertainment district or a neighborhood. And, if we want a destination entertainment area, I guess the parking issue becomes more important.
There are thousands of people that live within a 1/4 mile of 23rd. Hardly an area without residences. In fact there might be more humans in the 1/4 mile surrounding uptown 23rd than in a similar area around the Plaza District, due to more multi-family units in north Mesta Park/south Paso/south Jefferson Park.
The core "survived" (barely) for a long time despite the lack of a lot of services and amenities. However, Its revitalization is in large part due to the reemergence of these services. Downtown reestablished itself as a destination in large part because of restaurants and bars. Over the last ten years, we've seen that inspire various neighborhoods in the core to raise their profiles through the addition of bars and restaurants, and then retail. The Paseo is kind of a good case study on this effect. It had long been home to some of the art studios and galleries you see there now. It's core identity and image was already there, but it was the addition of Gallileo (now Picasso's), Isis (now named The Other Room, thankfully!), and the Paseo Grill that really elevated its profile and made it what it is today.
Eventually these places went from destination spots to places in which more people wanted to actually live. They transformed from sleepy neglected neighborhoods to vibrant urban districts in large part through the addition of restaurants. It's a formula that has been bringing older, often forgotten, areas of cities across the nation back to life for almost 25 years now. It has worked over and over again.
All that being said, even with a Cox store instead of a Cigar Bar and a mattress store instead of a retro pub, I agree that this development is still adding much to the district in the way of entertainment and retail and there's more coming that is not part of The Rise. Even with its hardships and delays, I still think it will be transformative and put the street "over the top" in terms of making it a viable place with good draw for many types of tenants. Uptown was long defined by three things things: Wig stores, a decaying Tower Theater, and a massive Hotel Motel liquidator, essentially a junk dealer. Those things (well, maybe not yet the wig stores) are becoming things of the past and with it so goes it's image of just another example of a once vibrant and now dilapidated shopping and entertainment district in the core of an American city.
Honestly, I always saw this part of 23rd as the perfect place for Oklahoma City to develop a small version of, say, a Lower Haight, Lower East side, or maybe an edgier retail sector like Melrose Ave. I was kind of skeptical, or maybe sorta disappointed, when they were looking to go "upscale". However, in the meantime, 16th street kind of became what I was thinking 23rd would be, so maybe a more diverse mix of tenants is what really does make sense now. We don't need two Plaza districts, so it is probably better for these developers to include tenants that cater to a broader cultural demographic. Not sure if a Cox store does this and it's certainly not flashy, but it's certainly a steady tenant. Almost everyone in OKC has Cox and because their equipment sucks, almost all of those people will need to go to a Cox store at some point and swap it out. It does create exposure across a broad, pretty much all encompassing, demographic.
If this was some wholesale conversion to 9-5 service and support tenants, then it would probably be cause for concern. But it's not, and Uptown will still be making a giant leap forward with this development along with the Tower complex coming back to life.
I modeled the pump after a lot of things I saw in Austin, central Colorado, San Diego, and San Francisco(in regards to the tiny, yet refined kitchen).
And in my travels there's no better example than south congress st in Austin. It, like 23rd is about a mile from Downtown, was once the main traffic artery through town (hiway 77 and hiway 66) mistreated, abused, and "urban renewal-ed" storefronts galore with a dense historic bungalow and multi tenant housing surrounding the area.
It is now an epicenter for funky culture, food trailer parks, bars, venues, the home slice compound (that's a pizza place that got so popular they opened another pizza place right next door, ironic hipster hilarity at it's peak).
Point is: it's a whole district of storefronts, albeit heavy on the food/entertainment. Not just one development on one block on one side of the street. There's blocks. And some of those storefronts are furniture shops, barber shops, a dollar store, and maybe even a cox cable.
We gotta look at the big picture here guys. One little cox store isn't going to ruin the district. A district which could potentially support the neighborhood in ADDITION to providing food and play to the hungry and bored. I think we know *coughbricktowncough* what can happen if a district is purely food/entertainment.
I believe in uptown. Enough to bet the farm on a crumbling gas station off-street before the rise had even broke ground. It's got plenty of room to grow. Plenty of room for cool developments and community infrastructure alike.
Now lets get that damn urban grocery store and set it off!
Don't forget to vote today!
+1
By the way, I doubted The Rise was ever going to be "upscale" even with the original tenant mix. A destination for OKC with fresh concepts people previously had to drive to Dallas or Tulsa for yes, but not "upscale" which in my opinion is an adjective thrown around way too loosely these days by developers.
Nonetheless, even with the downgraded tenant mix it is still a game changer for Uptown and still has enough new concepts to remain a destination. The district can really go nowhere but up.
You can all trumpet how great it is that we are getting a cox store. That doesn't change the fact that it's a huge disappointment that two quality establishments were forced to move because of delays.
We're talking about one single restaurant that is replaced with a Cox store. Steve already gave a list of all the tenants that are still staying in the Rise. TWO tenants left, that is it. I am perfectly fine with the Cox store. It has to go somewhere. 23rd district is not a big district. There are tons of new bars and restaurants that are opening up.
Of course any urban area needs all kinds of stores and services (e.g., the Cox Store), but these places are not what makes a city unique or distinct. No one ever goes to a city or a district and talks about the local cable store. It's the spaces/places where we meet with others and go with friends and families to be part of the community. Restaurants, bars, coffee shops, bowling alleys and the like allow community members to cultivate relationships and communities to forge identities. The Rise lost two places that offered community places that could have helped to make this a vibrant urban district that did just that. The Cox Store, a mattress store, and the tanning place (previously part of the development) will likely fail to do that. Fedora (correct me if I'm wrong) was going to provide the first outdoor rooftop space where people can gather in this district. All these reasons are why the changes in tenants are disappointing. This section of 23rd could have (and still could) really be a special place in OKC. It just took a bit of a step back now as a space/place for the local community.
I can tell you from the perspective of a friend who was actually involved in the development that there is plenty reason to "hate on" Land Run. There were definitely legitimate delays, but Land Run has made many mistakes as well that have caused more delays. You don't finish a development 1.5+ years after the planned date, without some major mistakes. The delays significantly affected the businesses that left the Rise.
From the perspective of someone who lives down the street from the Rise, as far as the tenants go...it's great that Land Run was able to get it completely leased again, but the new tenants are a downgrade and I'm not sure how that's even an argument. Instead of getting two bars/restaurants that will add many people to the street life in Uptown from midday until 2AM every day we're getting two stores that will only add 20-50 people a day to the street life on a good day between the hours of 9 AM and 7 PM. A cox store absolutely did not need to go somewhere in uptown because there is one about a mile away on 23rd St. Just think about it, how many times a week/month do you need to visit a cable provider physical location (or really per year after your initial set up)? How many times a week/month do you go to a store to look at or buy furniture? On the other side, how many times a week/month do you frequent a bar or restaurant? Losing Flashback and Fedora in Uptown because Land Run at least partially didn't know what they were getting into is a disappointment, the fact that they are being replaced by tenants that much fewer people will have a reason to visit makes it even more disappointing. Had Cox and a Furniture store been announced as the original tenants, while it wouldn't have been exciting, it wouldn't have been near as disappointing as losing better original tenants.
There are currently 89 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 89 guests)
Bookmarks