View Full Version : Everyone should get a flu shot
JohnH_in_OKC 10-19-2014, 08:08 AM Everyone should get their flu shots. From the CDC website (http://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/disease/us_flu-related_deaths.htm): CDC estimates that from the 1976-1977 season to the 2006-2007 flu season, flu-associated deaths ranged from a low of about 3,000 to a high of about 49,000 people (US deaths per flu season). From Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1918_flu_pandemic): The 1918 flu pandemic (January 1918 – December 1920) was an unusually deadly influenza pandemic, the first of the two pandemics involving H1N1 influenza virus. It infected 500 million people across the world, including remote Pacific islands and the Arctic, and killed 50 to 100 million of them—three to five percent of the world's population—making it one of the deadliest natural disasters in human history.
I plan on getting my flu shot on Monday at the VA.
9320
mkjeeves 10-19-2014, 08:30 AM I got one yesterday. I blame my wife.
Teo9969 10-19-2014, 09:04 AM I've never had a flu shot, and I'm still alive -^(':')^-
kevinpate 10-19-2014, 10:32 AM Sorry. Perhaps it was pure coincidence, but the one and only year I decided to go get a flu shot is the one and only year I ended up with a flu battle.
Perhaps it would have been worse sans that shot that year. But in the many, many years since that one bad experience, that has not been the case for me.
PennyQuilts 10-19-2014, 10:43 AM Wish I had gotten a "Cold" shot. :). Suffering through my first one in years.
RadicalModerate 10-19-2014, 11:38 AM I got my flu shot the other day. I don't think I've ever had the REAL "flu"--even though I just started getting flu shots, yearly, about nine years ago. Amazingly, last year I didn't even get a real cold. However, correlation isn't causation. Or non-causation, as the case may be. =)
p.s.: (re: colds): Zicam really seems to work for me. At the first sign of a cold you start taking it. It's actually just zinc and ascorbic acid. But for some reason--probably psychosomatic--it works.
PennyQuilts 10-19-2014, 11:45 AM U
I got my flu shot the other day. I don't think I've ever had the REAL "flu"--even though I just started getting flu shots, yearly, about nine years ago. Amazingly, last year I didn't even get a real cold. However, correlation isn't causation. Or non-causation, as the case may be. =)
p.s.: (re: colds): Zicam really seems to work for me. At the first sign of a cold you start taking it. It's actually just zinc and ascorbic acid. But for some reason--probably psychosomatic--it works.
Thanks. I am already on the mend!
mkjeeves 10-19-2014, 03:04 PM My wife gets a shot every year. I get one about every two or three years when she badgers me into it. We happened to be at Walgreens together when they weren't busy and when she brought it up. Bonus this time, we have a new insurance carrier this year and it was covered 100%. (Thanks, Obama!)
I'm generally pretty healthy and don't worry about it too much, but the two most ill times I have had as an adult were both flu and both before I started getting shots.
silvergrove 10-19-2014, 03:12 PM I mentioned this in the other virus thread but here goes:
A little unrelated but if everyone have or can get the influenza vaccine, you should do so.
As Ebola and the flu have similar initial symptoms, it's best we not clog up the hospitals emergency rooms as the flu season kicks in. I'm sure tons of people will flood the hospitals during the Ebola scare when they just have the flu. Especially with the Ebola craze, why stress the hospital systems even more? Consider it your patriotic duty!
I just got my vaccine last week, I got the live attenuated influenza vaccine instead.
Zuplar 10-19-2014, 03:58 PM I don't plan on getting one and don't want one.
RadicalModerate 10-19-2014, 05:58 PM I don't plan on getting one and don't want one.
Does that mean "a cold" . . . "a flu shot" . . . or a case of intestinal flu due to cross contamination from undercooked chicken?
p.s. I was one of those little kids, mention on The X-Files, who innocently lined up for Polio Vaccines and, later, Polio Sugar Cubes back in the day. =)
RadicalModerate 10-19-2014, 06:01 PM My wife gets a shot every year. I get one about every two or three years when she badgers me into it. We happened to be at Walgreens together when they weren't busy and when she brought it up. Bonus this time, we have a new insurance carrier this year and it was covered 100%. (Thanks, Obama!)
I'm generally pretty healthy and don't worry about it too much, but the two most ill times I have had as an adult were both flu and both before I started getting shots.
Did you consider getting a rabies shot at the same time? Badgers are notorious for carrying rabies.
Obviously the anti-tentanus (lockjaw) shots I had a few times when I was a kid were effective.
mkjeeves 10-19-2014, 06:24 PM Did you consider getting a rabies shot at the same time? Badgers are notorious for carrying rabies.
Obviously the anti-tentanus (lockjaw) shots I had a few times when I was a kid were effective.
They did try to upsell me with a Tdap shot. (Yeah, I had to ask what that was too.) I'm current on tetanus though and have been most of my life, with periodic qualifying injuries instigating them.
kevinpate 10-19-2014, 07:53 PM Oddly enough, no one tends to suggest a shot intended to prevent lockjaw to me.
Not real sure how to take that. :)
JohnH_in_OKC 10-20-2014, 07:31 AM Does that mean "a cold" . . . "a flu shot" . . . or a case of intestinal flu due to cross contamination from undercooked chicken?
p.s. I was one of those little kids, mention on The X-Files, who innocently lined up for Polio Vaccines and, later, Polio Sugar Cubes back in the day. =)
I had a friend with polio & an uncle who had polio as a child. Be very thankful that the polio vaccine saved thousands of children (and adults) from lives being crippled and paralyzed. My friend was often bedridden & wore braces on both of her legs & my uncle had to use a cane to walk.
From Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poliomyelitis): By 1910, much of the world experienced a dramatic increase in polio cases and epidemics became regular events, primarily in cities during the summer months. These epidemics—which left thousands of children and adults paralyzed—provided the impetus for a "Great Race" towards the development of a vaccine. Developed in the 1950s, polio vaccines have reduced the global number of polio cases per year from many hundreds of thousands to under a thousand today. Enhanced vaccination efforts led by Rotary International, the World Health Organization, and UNICEF should result in global eradication of the disease, although in 2013 there were reports by the World Health Organization of new cases in Syria.
kelroy55 10-20-2014, 08:21 AM Wish I had gotten a "Cold" shot. :). Suffering through my first one in years.
Alka Seltzer Cold Plus has always worked well for me.
kelroy55 10-20-2014, 08:24 AM I had a friend with polio & an uncle who had polio as a child. Be very thankful that the polio vaccine saved thousands of children (and adults) from lives being crippled and paralyzed. My friend was often bedridden & wore braces on both of her legs & my uncle had to use a cane to walk.
My dad had Polio and had to wear a brace when he was younger and had a limp his whole life.
PennyQuilts 10-20-2014, 08:29 AM Polio is a bad deal ( Understatement). I was one of the lucky ones to be able to get the sugar cube fix. What a magnificent public health success story! Few of my contemporaries got polio, unlike the generations before. The few that did really struggled with the braces and notable limps. I never worried about my kids getting polio but my grandparents didn't have that sort of peace of mind. I wonder if modern day prosthetics are more helpful for people with polio.
OKCisOK4me 10-20-2014, 09:13 PM Sorry, not getting a flu shot but good luck to you.
I remember the sugar cube med. Of course at that age the only thing that mattered was getting that sugar cube. A one day sore arm muscle was all I got from my flu shot. I'm sure my Grandsons will test it's effect.
betts 10-21-2014, 06:09 AM GYou absolutely cannot get the flu from a flu shot because the virus isn't live. It's coincidence when people say they got the flu the same year they got the shot. Many viruses mimic the flu and the rapid flu test isn't that reliable, so you don't always know when you have it......or don't. The flu is particularly dangerous to the young and elderly, as well as anyone with lung disease. I get the shot every year and work directly with many, many kids who have the flu every winter and I haven't had the virus in years. The year all 3 of my kids got the flu I didn't catch it. Infectious disease doctors say if you're immunized and still get the flu, you will generally have a milder case of the disease than if you weren't immunized.
However, the nasal vaccine is not killed, only attenuated or weakened, and so it is theoretically possible to get the flu from it. That's not usually the case though.
BBatesokc 10-21-2014, 06:19 AM Been trying to get my Flu shot (as I 100% agree that everyone should get one - its a public safety issue in my mind) but the two places I've walked in to so far only had shots that covered 2 strains and not 4.
MadMonk 10-21-2014, 11:07 AM Got my flu shot today. I didn't even feel it, but my arm is getting slightly sore. I'll report back if I wake up dead or something. ;)
ctchandler 10-21-2014, 11:34 AM GYou absolutely cannot get the flu from a flu shot because the virus isn't live. It's coincidence when people say they got the flu the same year they got the shot. Many viruses mimic the flu and the rapid flu test isn't that reliable, so you don't always know when you have it......or don't. The flu is particularly dangerous to the young and elderly, as well as anyone with lung disease. I get the shot every year and work directly with many, many kids who have the flu every winter and I haven't had the virus in years. The year all 3 of my kids got the flu I didn't catch it. Infectious disease doctors say if you're immunized and still get the flu, you will generally have a milder case of the disease than if you weren't immunized.
However, the nasal vaccine is not killed, only attenuated or weakened, and so it is theoretically possible to get the flu from it. That's not usually the case though.
Betts,
I suspect some of the older folks that say they got the flu did receive the live virus vaccination, but that hasn't been used since the 90's. And even then, it was a mild version. I have always tried to get a flu shot since my wife was a nurse, but one year I didn't, 1999 and neither did Dianna. I think I caught it from her and for almost two weeks, we spent most of the day in bed, praying for death but of course I had to get up once in a while to go outside and smoke. But, I was so sick that I couldn't inhale and on December 29th, 1999 I decided that since I had gone over a week without inhaling, I could quit, and I did! The one good thing the flu did for me.
C. T.
PennyQuilts 10-21-2014, 12:04 PM Cc
Betts,
I suspect some of the older folks that say they got the flu did receive the live virus vaccination, but that hasn't been used since the 90's. And even then, it was a mild version. I have always tried to get a flu shot since my wife was a nurse, but one year I didn't, 1999 and neither did Dianna. I think I caught it from her and for almost two weeks, we spent most of the day in bed, praying for death but of course I had to get up once in a while to go outside and smoke. But, I was so sick that I couldn't inhale and on December 29th, 1999 I decided that since I had gone over a week without inhaling, I could quit, and I did! The one good thing the flu did for me.
C. T.
That entire post was a delight to read. You told the story so well.
Prunepicker 10-22-2014, 09:02 PM I'm thinking about getting one. It's been a couple of years.
Plutonic Panda 10-23-2014, 01:33 AM GYou absolutely cannot get the flu from a flu shot because the virus isn't live. It's coincidence when people say they got the flu the same year they got the shot. Many viruses mimic the flu and the rapid flu test isn't that reliable, so you don't always know when you have it......or don't. The flu is particularly dangerous to the young and elderly, as well as anyone with lung disease. I get the shot every year and work directly with many, many kids who have the flu every winter and I haven't had the virus in years. The year all 3 of my kids got the flu I didn't catch it. Infectious disease doctors say if you're immunized and still get the flu, you will generally have a milder case of the disease than if you weren't immunized.
However, the nasal vaccine is not killed, only attenuated or weakened, and so it is theoretically possible to get the flu from it. That's not usually the case though.
It's always a coincidence ;)
RadicalModerate 10-23-2014, 01:38 AM I've had no ill effects from the flu shot I got a couple of weeks ago.
I'm beginning to suspect it was a placebo.
RadicalModerate 10-23-2014, 01:43 AM It's always a coincidence ;)
Coincidence is NOT Causation. Not to mention Correlation.
(and vice-versa, to the third power)
(although I had a brief bout with what some refer to as Shingles, I'm not scrambling to the inoculators for a vaccine for that. too many TV ads have sort of put me off the validity of whatever claims they make about that preventative course of treatment. the flu shot, however, seems to work.)
I think a significant portion of the anti-inoculation brigade are simply afraid of needles.
Perhaps due to the subliminal influence of Canadians like this?:
k0t0EW6z8a0
=)
Plutonic Panda 10-23-2014, 02:14 AM Coincidence is NOT Causation. Not to mention Correlation.
(and vice-versa, to the third power)
(although I had a brief bout with what some refer to as Shingles, I'm not scrambling to the inoculators for a vaccine for that. too many TV ads have sort of put me off the validity of whatever claims they make about that preventative course of treatment. the flu shot, however, seems to work.)
I think a significant portion of the anti-inoculation brigade are simply afraid of needles.
Perhaps due to the subliminal influence of Canadians like this?:
k0t0EW6z8a0
=)that may be, but remember, your post was posted right after mine... coincidence. . . I THINK NOT!
rezman 10-23-2014, 05:54 AM Up until last week, it had been a few years since I have received a flu shot. Last week, our company was offering shots, so I went ahead and got one this time. I figure since I'm getting older, it's probably not a bad idea.
The problem I've seen over the years is coworkers who insist on coming to work when they're sick. Just two days ago we had a guy trying to decide whether to go to the doctor or not and was walking around the shop and the offices telling everyone how he feels like crud, and was trying to figure out what to do.
I try to wash my hands often, and If I'm sick, which is not very often, I stay home.
ctchandler 10-23-2014, 02:10 PM (although I had a brief bout with what some refer to as Shingles, I'm not scrambling to the inoculators for a vaccine for that. too many TV ads have sort of put me off the validity of whatever claims they make about that preventative course of treatment. the flu shot, however, seems to work.)=)
RM,
I wouldn't try to convince you otherwise, but I have had shingles and the pain is unbelievable and my boss got them in his back and he couldn't even come to work. The shingles vaccine is advertised (well, not advertised, but if you read the fine print) as only 50 percent effective, but with my experience, it's worth a little stick in the arm, just in case because I don't want to feel that pain again. And there was no pain or side effects to the vaccine for me.
C. T.
p.s. To get shingles, you must have had chicken pox. Well I knew and my mother knew (she was a spry 78 when I got the shingles) that I had never had chicken pox. Well, I guess one slipped by us, because I must have contracted it when my sister had them but I didn't know it and neither did my mother.
|
|