View Full Version : Tulsa, Not OKC, Is Getting a Hard Rock



Pages : [1] 2 3

dismayed
07-24-2009, 02:37 PM
I know this has been discussed in the Tulsa forum, but in case you didn't see it the Tulsa metro area (on Cherokee Nation land) is getting a Hard Rock Hotel and Casino (links below).

The intent of this post isn't to announce it but is really to discuss... why? I'm happy for the Tulsa area and think it's great, I will certainly be traveling up the road to see it, but why is it that since almost day one we have been talking about having a Hard Rock Cafe in Bricktown but could never really pull it off, but the Cherokee Nation somehow managed to swing a deal. What is it that they did that we have not? Is it purely a matter of the casino gambling, or is it something else? What could we have done differently to have seen this developed in the OKC area?

Thoughts?

Hard Rock Casino Tulsa (2009) (http://500nations.com/casinos/okHardRockCasinoTulsa.asp)

Hard Rock Hotel & Casino | About Us | Press Release Detail (http://www.hardrockhotel.com/pressdetail.cfm?id=28)

Pete
07-24-2009, 02:46 PM
First of all, this is just buying the Hard Rock brand for a complex almost completed.

Secondly, it is merely a franchise of their name.

And third, the Hard Rock brand is now owned by the Seminole Tribe.

Steve
07-24-2009, 02:57 PM
Pete's right. Hard Rock Cafe, by the way, is a 1990s definition of a city achieving big league success. The brand follows tribal casinos, and locations are no longer determined by urban hipness, etc.

Pete
07-24-2009, 03:14 PM
One of the original, signature Hard Rock Cafes (the one in the Beverly Center with the Cadillac sticking out of it's facade) closed here in Los Angeles and barely a soul noticed.

dmoor82
07-24-2009, 03:20 PM
Do you really want to go into what OKC is getting/has and what Tulsa is not? cuz we can and it would be mindblowing!!!1

Stinger
07-24-2009, 03:23 PM
Yeah, but if they get the WNBA too, it's a wash.

Stinger
07-24-2009, 03:23 PM
One of the original, signature Hard Rock Cafes (the one in the Beverly Center with the Cadillac sticking out of it's facade) closed here in Los Angeles and barely a soul noticed.

Same thing happened in Dallas (Although not really a signature HRC)

dmoor82
07-24-2009, 03:27 PM
Yeah, but if they get the WNBA too, it's a wash.

LOL!!! that is funny,WNBA is Good for Tulsa it brings the city's national image status up! and having a Hard Rock Hotel/Casino,while cool is hardly something to brag about,give me an NBA team and a 925 ft tower over a faded brand casino any day of the week!!!!!Tulsa is outdoing OKC??????? LMFAO!

fuzzytoad
07-24-2009, 03:53 PM
LOL!!! that is funny,WNBA is Good for Tulsa it brings the city's national image status up! and having a Hard Rock Hotel/Casino,while cool is hardly something to brag about,give me an NBA team and a 925 ft tower over a faded brand casino any day of the week!!!!!Tulsa is outdoing OKC??????? LMFAO!

you forgot about the banjo museum

dmoor82
07-24-2009, 03:56 PM
you forgot about the banjo museum

And you forgot about the Dave and Busters!!!!,thats what the title of this thread should be-Tulsa is getinng a D&B,not OKC!!!!LOL I think SOME Tulsan's are still bitter about OKC getting an NBA team,and it being called the Oklahoma city thunder and not the Oklahoma -------!Yeah I said it so what!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

fuzzytoad
07-24-2009, 04:05 PM
And you forgot about the Dave and Busters!!!!,thats what the title of this thread should be-Tulsa is getinng a D&B,not OKC!!!!LOL

yeah, nevermind, you obviously missed the point.

dmoor82
07-24-2009, 04:10 PM
yeah, nevermind, you obviously missed the point.

I guess I did,my bad,the title of this thread is so stupid,it's like who gives a shi-!I'm just getting defensive for no reason!i'm done with this thread!

pokemike
07-24-2009, 04:13 PM
First of all, this is just buying the Hard Rock brand for a complex almost completed.

Secondly, it is merely a franchise of their name.

And third, the Hard Rock brand is now owned by the Seminole Tribe.

This is correct. It will not actually be a Hard Rock, the Cherokees just bought the name rights for their place. I know some folks at the Seminole Gaming in Florida who are none-too-happy about this. They're pissed that Hard Rock is seeling it's name to just anyone right now (including Kansas City Motor Speedway's bar), when the Seminoles were supposed to have exclusive rights.

progressiveboy
07-24-2009, 04:15 PM
Same thing happened in Dallas (Although not really a signature HRC) Actually that is true, it closed about 2 years ago on McKinney Avenue, however they just had there grand reopening on July 15 in Victory Park. The HR officials stated they missed being in Dallas and wanted to re enter the market

dismayed
07-24-2009, 04:18 PM
For the malcontents who refuse to read what I originally posted, the point was that the city of Oklahoma City and/or Bricktown leaders, in articles in various newspapers going back a decade, said that they were actively trying to get a Hard Rock in Bricktown. The question wasn't about whether or not early 21st Century tastes have evolved, it was simply why, if we wanted one, we didn't get one, but another city in Oklahoma, that did want a Hard Rock, did get one.

Pete
07-24-2009, 04:23 PM
dismayed, these are not the same things though.

I don't think anyone was clamoring for a Hard Rock Indian casino in Bricktown.

fuzzytoad
07-24-2009, 04:23 PM
For the malcontents who refuse to read what I originally posted, the point was that the city of Oklahoma City said it wanted a Hard Rock and early posts in The Oklahoman that interviewed Bricktown leaders said they were actively trying to get a Hard Rock into town. The question wasn't about whether or not early 21st Century tastes have evolved, it was simply why, if we wanted one, we didn't get one, but another city in Oklahoma, that did want a Hard Rock, did get one.

Probably something to do with the gambling aspect of it.

I can't believe there's no casinos in OKC, especially in or around Bricktown and I believe I read on this forum somewhere that it was the fault of whatever group of people control Bricktown.

dismayed
07-24-2009, 04:25 PM
dismayed, these are not the same things though.

I don't think anyone was clamoring for a Hard Rock Indian casino in Bricktown.

Ok, fair enough.

adaniel
07-24-2009, 04:44 PM
Probably something to do with the gambling aspect of it.

I can't believe there's no casinos in OKC, especially in or around Bricktown and I believe I read on this forum somewhere that it was the fault of whatever group of people control Bricktown.

I don't think it has anything to do with that. It is probably because most of OKC lies in land that was never assigned to any one tribe. On the flip side, Tulsa straddles both the Creek and Cherokee Nation. Hence why several large casinos lie right outside the metro (Riverwind, Firelake Grand) but Tulsa have casinos within its city limits.The "Racino" at Remington Park has gambling only because the racetrack was bleeding money, but feel free to correct me if that's not accurate.

As someone who used to frequent the Hard Rock Cafe in Dallas when I was a kid, that brand has slowly gone downhill as well as Planet Hollywood. There hasn't been a new cafe in the US in quite some time and, as has been mentioned, the hotels only open up with adjoining casinos.

mburlison
07-24-2009, 04:45 PM
Judging by the few I've been to, the HR's are over rated in my opinion.

oustud7
07-24-2009, 05:05 PM
I agree when people say that hard rock cafe isn't a yardstick by which to measure a city anymore. I dont think its any more special than the cheesecake factory at this point. Maybe it was 15 years ago, but a lot of other things have changed since then. Its just another chain bar/restaurant. And in oklahoma, just another indian casino.

Steve
07-24-2009, 05:23 PM
For the malcontents who refuse to read what I originally posted, the point was that the city of Oklahoma City and/or Bricktown leaders, in articles in various newspapers going back a decade, said that they were actively trying to get a Hard Rock in Bricktown. The question wasn't about whether or not early 21st Century tastes have evolved, it was simply why, if we wanted one, we didn't get one, but another city in Oklahoma, that did want a Hard Rock, did get one.


Dismayed, I don't want to come off as arogant and a know-it-all here and I hope people don't think that after reading this. I've been the guy covering this beat now more than a dozen years, and your comments about the city/Bricktown pursuing a Hard Rock Cafe simply is not true. There were never (to my knowledge) any public pronouncements about trying to become home to a Hard Rock Cafe. I challenge you to produce a legitimate newspaper story (Oklahoman, JR, Gazette) that says otherwise.
I'm not accusing of lying. But I do think you've fallen into the trap of buying into an urban legend.
For what it's worth, I'm betting the addition of the Academy of Contemporary Music to Bricktown - something you won't find in any other urban entertainment district in America - will have far more impact than a Hard Rock Cafe.

Steve
07-24-2009, 05:26 PM
Probably something to do with the gambling aspect of it.

I can't believe there's no casinos in OKC, especially in or around Bricktown and I believe I read on this forum somewhere that it was the fault of whatever group of people control Bricktown.

More clarification is needed here: a state compact that allowed Remington Park to create a Racino and the tribes to do Class II casinos is what prohibits any other casinos from opening shop in Oklahoma City. Oklahoma City was part of the unassigned lands. And that's why a tribe can't set up a casino here - they can only do so on tribal land.

bluedogok
07-24-2009, 05:43 PM
One of the original, signature Hard Rock Cafes (the one in the Beverly Center with the Cadillac sticking out of it's facade) closed here in Los Angeles and barely a soul noticed.
The one here in Austin closed in early 2006, it was pretty much deserted every night on Sixth Street while all the other bars were open. The thing that killed them here was it was supposed to be a rock club but never had any live music.

Thunder
07-24-2009, 06:55 PM
This Hard Rock Cafe, is this the one that was in the movie, Honey I Blew Up the Kid?

Midtowner
07-24-2009, 07:28 PM
The one here in Austin closed in early 2006, it was pretty much deserted every night on Sixth Street while all the other bars were open. The thing that killed them here was it was supposed to be a rock club but never had any live music.

The few times I've been to one, it has just been so-so casual dining with some so-so memorabilia on the walls.

It's a washed up brand. It's found new life in trashy Indian casinos. Good for it, I guess.

Patrick
07-24-2009, 07:29 PM
I agree. Hard Rock Cafes are so 1990's. They're not in any favor anymore. And like Steve said, OKC never actively sought one. The only major chain restaurants I can think of that were ever mentioned were Dick Clark's American Bandstand Grill, by Randy Hogan. Moshe Tal suggested bringing Hard Rock and ESPN Zone to Bricktown, but this was nothing ever more than just a thought, and no attempts were ever made to attract these tenants to Bricktown. I personally don't see Hard Rock any more special than Toby Keith's, and I'm not really a fan of Toby Keith's.

fuzzytoad
07-24-2009, 09:20 PM
More clarification is needed here: a state compact that allowed Remington Park to create a Racino and the tribes to do Class II casinos is what prohibits any other casinos from opening shop in Oklahoma City. Oklahoma City was part of the unassigned lands. And that's why a tribe can't set up a casino here - they can only do so on tribal land.

ahh, thanks!

mugofbeer
07-24-2009, 09:25 PM
Whatever happened to the rumors I had heard a year ago about a Hard Rock Casino being built out like at Hefner or Brittan and I-35?

kevinpate
07-24-2009, 09:29 PM
same thing that happened to the rumor I would some day again be thin and finally become handsome ... someone got it very, very wrong
8^)

mugofbeer
07-24-2009, 09:31 PM
Hey, I heard that same rumor about me! It also included whispers about great wealth.

Patrick
07-24-2009, 09:49 PM
Whatever happened to the rumors I had heard a year ago about a Hard Rock Casino being built out like at Hefner or Brittan and I-35?

You're referring to the Shawnee tribe's planned $400 million casino.

mugofbeer
07-24-2009, 09:55 PM
It may have been. I thought I had heard the Hard Rock name associated with it. I just hadn't heard it again and the thread reminded me.

Patrick
07-24-2009, 10:00 PM
By the way, this NEW Hard Rock casino in Tulsa is not really new. It's just a renaming of Cherokee Casino and Resort. I don't see the big deal. Cherokee Casino has been there on the eastern side of Tulsa for some time now. Sure, they're expanding again, but a tribal casino is a tribal casino.

In_Tulsa
07-25-2009, 06:56 AM
You can dog it all you want but with only 7 in the world www.hardrockhotels.com is coming to Tulsa its going to be HUGE just watch this will be fun. They will also be doing national TV advertising. It will be bigger than you think.



www.hardrockcasinotulsa.com

andimthomas
07-25-2009, 08:07 AM
You can dog it all you want but with only 7 in the world Hard Rock Hotels (http://www.hardrockhotels.com) is coming to Tulsa its going to be HUGE just watch this will be fun. They will also be doing national TV advertising. It will be bigger than you think.



Pages - default (http://www.hardrockcasinotulsa.com)

Because the entire nation will travel to Oklahoma instead of Vegas, Orlando, San Diego, or Chicago for a Hard Rock :|

DM1031
07-25-2009, 08:25 AM
I am in Tulsa, so let me chime in on the Hard Rock issue, I hate it.
I was a fan of the old HRC, when they were cool to go to, each one unique, now they are washed up.
The one here is just a Hard Rock sign on the old Cherokee casino, still owned and managed by the Cherokee casino, just a sign and some crappy t-shirts.
There will not even be a Hard Rock Cafe, that is the foundation of the whole brand, isnt it?
Toby Keith had a deal in place for a bar & grill inside of the Cherokee, it opens in a week or so, that is why there will be no HRC.
A Toby Keith restaurant inside the Hard Rock? not very hard rock is it?
and they will still have the section of the casino devoted to country music, again, not very hard rock.
Not to mention its not even in Tulsa, its in Catoosa.

I would much rather see an ESPN Zone, and Bricktown would be the perfect place, Tulsa would not be a good fit, seeing that all we have in sports is a minor league baseball team, an arena football team, and it looks as if we will have a WNBA team, big deal.


OK, done venting, back to you Bob

dismayed
07-25-2009, 10:34 AM
Dismayed, I don't want to come off as arogant and a know-it-all here and I hope people don't think that after reading this. I've been the guy covering this beat now more than a dozen years, and your comments about the city/Bricktown pursuing a Hard Rock Cafe simply is not true. There were never (to my knowledge) any public pronouncements about trying to become home to a Hard Rock Cafe. I challenge you to produce a legitimate newspaper story (Oklahoman, JR, Gazette) that says otherwise.
I'm not accusing of lying. But I do think you've fallen into the trap of buying into an urban legend.
For what it's worth, I'm betting the addition of the Academy of Contemporary Music to Bricktown - something you won't find in any other urban entertainment district in America - will have far more impact than a Hard Rock Cafe.

You know, it is interesting. I've gone through some old Oklahoman articles, lots of Journal Record archives, well known Oklahoma blog posts, and even dug deep through the Internet archives at archive.org.

It looks to me like the Hard Rock idea started being thrown around when developers Moshe Tal and David Cordish hit the scene. Lots of talk about their past development in Baltimore that included a Hard Rock and a Barnes and Noble, and lots and lots of speculation about similar developments here, if their plan moved forward. Journal Record is a good source for that. I do consider them Bricktown developers, just like I do so many others who have proposed ideas for housing and other things downtown but, like Tal, have eventually failed and moved on.

Perhaps that idea "officially" did die with them leaving Bricktown. But the interesting thing is how many times "Hard Rock" is mentioned by folks around OKC. It seems that everyone constantly compares any development in Bricktown to the Hard Rock Cafe. I found loads of posts by random people comparing Toby Keith's to a country Hard Rock Cafe when it first opened. I even found a jab at Hard Rock on your own blog when comparing it to the School of Rock opening downtown. References are everywhere. I can even clearly remember a TV news anchor, shortly after major development started in Bricktown, closing a news segment about future developments with something like "...perhaps even a Hard Rock Cafe."

Perhaps it is an urban legend, I guess no one would know unless someone were to call up Moshe and ask for a clarification on what he was wanting to do 10 years ago, but certainly both the general populace and the professional media alike have played into it.

If no one in Bricktown ownership ever wanted or tried to get a Hard Rock, okay fine, no big deal then glad to know it wasn't that Tulsa had a better deal or something like that. I guess in that scenario the only thing that surprises me is, with a clearly wide base of support for such an idea, why no one ever seriously considered it....

mugofbeer
07-25-2009, 10:44 AM
I dont know. I just don't see what is so hot about getting a Hard Rock Cafe or hotel, getting Dave & Busters, getting this or getting that. I would far prefer to see some locally owned and operated facility than putting more money in nameless faceless corporations that really don't add anything. Look at what they are doing to the San Antonio riverwalk. Its all chains. Its lost much of its character because the chains have made it unaffordable for the local people to operate there

Mr. T in OKC
07-25-2009, 10:52 AM
This Hard Rock Cafe, is this the one that was in the movie, Honey I Blew Up the Kid?


Someone watched "Honey I Blew Up the Kid"?

dalelakin
07-25-2009, 04:45 PM
More clarification is needed here: a state compact that allowed Remington Park to create a Racino and the tribes to do Class II casinos is what prohibits any other casinos from opening shop in Oklahoma City. Oklahoma City was part of the unassigned lands. And that's why a tribe can't set up a casino here - they can only do so on tribal land.

Can't unassigned land be reassigned as tribal land though?

Steve
07-25-2009, 04:55 PM
Dalelakin, that's what the Shawnees were trying to do. Not likely, but who's to say for sure.
Dismayed, I'll leave it to others to discuss the Moshe Tal's credibility, etc.

kevinpate
07-25-2009, 08:31 PM
wouldn't a more accurate thread title be something like ....

Tulsa 'burb, not OKC 'burb, is getting the Hard Rock brand slapped on an existing casino/hotel

evh5150
07-25-2009, 08:47 PM
ive always thought Tulsa to be a more commercially marketable city than Oklahoma City, simply because the name of their town only has two syllables, whereas ours has six.

most major cities have few syllables in them:

Dallas
Houston
Miami
Seattle
Denver
Phoenix

..even Los Angeles and New York City, have just four syllables

six syllables is a hard push for commercial growth

not really sure why that seems to be, but i have noticed it.

dismayed
07-25-2009, 09:15 PM
I dont know. I just don't see what is so hot about getting a Hard Rock Cafe or hotel, getting Dave & Busters, getting this or getting that. I would far prefer to see some locally owned and operated facility than putting more money in nameless faceless corporations that really don't add anything. Look at what they are doing to the San Antonio riverwalk. Its all chains. Its lost much of its character because the chains have made it unaffordable for the local people to operate there

I don't disagree.

Tom Elmore
07-26-2009, 12:53 PM
I don't pretend to know a thing about HARD ROCK Cafes. I've honestly never been in one that I recall. I can say, however, that the HARD ROCK Cafe that was in the vanguard of a surge in commercial development along McKinney Avenue in Dallas back in the 1980s is often said to have been drawn there by the McKinney Avenue Transit operation, vintage trolleys that first operated on 1887 rail line uncovered on that street.

Those trolleys and the access they offer is widely credited with creating over $100 million in new commercial development in the area they serve in their first nine years of operation. The system was funded on a shoestring, and, as far as I know, continues to be operated now as then mostly by well-trained volunteers.

When McKinney Avenue Transit Authority CEO John Landrum came here at my organization's request in 1999 to make a presentation about its success to a Citizens League transit forum at Metro Tech, an OKC Chamber operative who functioned as the forum's moderator apparently appointed the League, would not allow him to make that presentation.

How much of the original Oklahoma Railway trolley lines still lies under the asphalt in OKC's streets? Less now than then, you can be certain. What would the cost be of putting these back into operation with real, vintage trolleys? Would the appeal of such a system be superior to the "modern streetcars" some are suggesting -- or could a vintage system be run very inexpensively in parallel with the modern streetcars to give wider initial coverage?

Perhaps we should ask John Landrum and some of his associates to come back here to OKC to talk to the citizenry and leadership about it -- with the assurance that The Chamber and its operatives would not be allowed to interfere.

Platemaker
07-26-2009, 03:48 PM
Would the appeal of such a system be superior to the "modern streetcars"

Definitely not. There is a "coolness" factor to modern streetcars that the vintage cars don't have. I think modern riders (and upcoming generations - Ages 30 and younger) prefer the modern streetcars.


or could a vintage system be run very inexpensively in parallel with the modern streetcars to give wider initial coverage?

In OKC's case... maybe on the centennial project from Bricktown to the Adventure District.

.... but this thread is about HRC. :backtotop

bluedogok
07-26-2009, 04:12 PM
I was a fan of the old HRC, when they were cool to go to, each one unique, now they are washed up.
It was run into the ground by a corporate mindset after the founders sold out in 1990, they have expanded to 140 locations, that has devalued the brand more than anything, the Seminole Nation bought it in 2006. In 1992 Isaac Tigrett founded the House of Blues in Chicago, it took over as the "in" place back then after the new HRC owners showed the willingness to open one up almost anywhere. I don't doubt that if Tal would have been successful over Hogan that a HRC location would have been in Bricktown because for awhile that all you had to have was to meet the investment criteria. Tigrett sold HOB to LiveNation in 2006 which I am sure will bring a decline to the chain although most still have live music in them and since LiveNation is one of the large concert promoters it may not go down as quickly.

The HRC "brand" is a shell of what it used to be, over exposure killed whatever cache it used to have. I will say that the Tulsa area getting the hotel/casino under their ownership is probably a very good thing as the Seminole Nation has proven to be a pretty stable ownership group in their many different ventures.

Matt
07-26-2009, 04:32 PM
When I saw some dude walking around in a "Hard Rock Cafe: Wichita Falls" t-shirt, that was the day I knew the Hard Rock Cafe franchise had officially jumped the shark.

oneforone
07-26-2009, 04:40 PM
Hard Rock is not anything special in my opinion. I have dined at several over the years. It's just like eating at Chili's, Fridays or any other theme restaurant. The only real difference is they have a gift shop with overpriced junk.

The worst theme restaurant I have ever ate at was Planet Hollywood. The food was bland and extremely over priced.

Steve
07-26-2009, 06:04 PM
Oneforone, this might interest you: Planet Hollywood actually did look at coming to Lower Bricktown in the late 1990s.
Now, for the rest of this debate, let's go with the premise that Moshe Tal, who had no development experience and never showed proof of financing other than stating he had unnamed investors from South America, actually got to develop Lower Bricktown instead of Randy Hogan.
And let's presume the Moshe Tal got to build everything and signed up a Hard Rock Cafe. Considering that the Hard Rock Cafes in Dallas and Austin have since closed, do you think the one here would have survived more than a few years?

progressiveboy
07-26-2009, 07:07 PM
Oneforone, this might interest you: Planet Hollywood actually did look at coming to Lower Bricktown in the late 1990s.
Now, for the rest of this debate, let's go with the premise that Moshe Tal, who had no development experience and never showed proof of financing other than stating he had unnamed investors from South America, actually got to develop Lower Bricktown instead of Randy Hogan.
And let's presume the Moshe Tal got to build everything and signed up a Hard Rock Cafe. Considering that the Hard Rock Cafes in Dallas and Austin have since closed, do you think the one here would have survived more than a few years? Actually HR did close in Dallas where they were located on McKinney Ave, however, as I previously posted, HR Cafe has reopened in Dallas which had their grand reopening on July 15. They are located in Victory Park. The local news station in DFW stated they missed being in Dallas and they are very happy to be back in Big D.

jbrown84
07-26-2009, 09:53 PM
Point being, Progressive, that if HRC can't survive in Austin, then it probably wouldn't have lasted here for long.

Toby Keith's is a pretty good substitute.

andimthomas
07-26-2009, 10:04 PM
Yeahh okay all the TV commercials and billboard advertising are getting annoying already.

Jesseda
07-27-2009, 09:07 AM
hard rock cafe is like any other place its is expanding and opening up in almost every state, soon it will be like a chilis, every city over 20,000 people will have one lol..

bluedogok
07-27-2009, 09:19 AM
Point being, Progressive, that if HRC can't survive in Austin, then it probably wouldn't have lasted here for long.
I actually think it could survive in OKC easier than it could in Austin. When it comes to Central Austin it is very much a more locally oriented town, that is what the "Keep Austin Weird" campaign is all about. I went into the HRC here once and it seemed no different than the other ones that I had been to before, there was no "localization" of the Austin location or if there was it was hard to find. That pretty much is the opposite of what Central Austin is about and the fact they rarely had live music there pretty much doomed them in this market, I think the only times that it ever had much of a crowd was during SXSW. OKC doesn't have the same type of identity so I think it would be a little easier to survive there. It probably would have survived better being out in one of the North Austin burbs rather than on Sixth Street. I think the House of Blues would have a hard time here, Antone's is already considered that here.

hoya
07-27-2009, 10:34 AM
I only went into a HRC once. It was just a restaurant with a bunch of crap on the walls. I bought an overpriced jacket. Kind of neat, but I didn't get the feeling that it was in any way "special". I feel the same way about Dave and Busters, too. It's just a place to eat with some video games. Eh.

Patrick
07-27-2009, 03:20 PM
Now, for the rest of this debate, let's go with the premise that Moshe Tal, who had no development experience and never showed proof of financing other than stating he had unnamed investors from South America, actually got to develop Lower Bricktown instead of Randy Hogan.

Actually, I have copies of his approval letters for intent to finance from Bank One and Midfirst Bank. So, yes, he did continually state he had "foreign investors" but he had letters of intent from local banks as well.


And let's presume the Moshe Tal got to build everything and signed up a Hard Rock Cafe. Considering that the Hard Rock Cafes in Dallas and Austin have since closed, do you think the one here would have survived more than a few years?

Wouldn't be any different than the deals with Edwards Theatres, Dick Clark's American Bandstand Grill, Sega Gameworks, etc. falling through, all of which Hogan promised, and supposedly had letters of intent from.

dismayed
07-27-2009, 08:38 PM
Oneforone, this might interest you: Planet Hollywood actually did look at coming to Lower Bricktown in the late 1990s.
Now, for the rest of this debate, let's go with the premise that Moshe Tal, who had no development experience and never showed proof of financing other than stating he had unnamed investors from South America, actually got to develop Lower Bricktown instead of Randy Hogan.
And let's presume the Moshe Tal got to build everything and signed up a Hard Rock Cafe. Considering that the Hard Rock Cafes in Dallas and Austin have since closed, do you think the one here would have survived more than a few years?

I have a question, because I don't know all that transpired with this Moshe Tal guy. But in researching articles in the Journal Record, I found many references to him having a business partner called David Cordish. I just did a search and found a very impressive website that seems to belong to this Mr. Cordish with some very impressive downtown developments, some of which I have actually been to and didn't realize he was the developer:

The Cordish Companies (http://www.cordish.com/sub.cfm?section=newdev)


I guess I just don't understand what happened. I would think that one unknown guy with money plus one well known developer is the way a lot of business deals go. As best I can tell from this article:

Bricktown theater plan gets thumbs-up | Journal Record, The (Oklahoma City) | Find Articles at BNET (http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4182/is_19980610/ai_n10118102/)


The mayor and council at the time were concerned about having an out-of-stater do the development. I think the article above is kind of ironic in hindsight since it talks about who will ultimately be able to produce the downtown products (clearly favoring the Oklahoma company) and then goes on to list a bunch of stuff that we never received. I mean was this really what it came down to... who was local?

Steve
07-27-2009, 08:47 PM
Letters of intent are non-binding experessions of interest, not proof of financing. That having been said, it's clear looking back that the city might have missed out on getting a great developer like Cordish because of who he was teamed up with. The problem I observed was Cordish never came to Oklahoma City or sent representatives until the political waters were poisoned over the Moshe Tal debates. He let Tal do all the speaking until the last hour and by then the hatred, right or wrong, for Tal, pretty much targeted anyone associated with Tal.
Of course all this is history now and be debated forever.
To this date Tal has done nothing with the property he still owns in Bricktown and has spent over a decade waging lawsuits.
For what it's worth, Moshe Tal may be one of the smartest men I've ever met. I say that with all sincerity. Just not sure he knew how get a deal done in this town. On the flip side, those who follow my coverage know I've given Tal's rival, Randy Hogan, a hard time over the design of Lower Bricktown, especially when it came to The Centennial.
I just don't get this whole love affair with Hard Rock Cafe and those who think it bestows big league city status.